Written By Emily Formby, Charity Recruit

Emily Formby, Divisional Director at Charity Recruit, has noticed a troubling pattern in the charity sector over the past year. Conversations with industry peers and her own network suggest that a number of senior leadership roles are opening up in the wake of fraud, rather than through resignation or retirement.

The costliest frauds are often the dullest. A fabricated name sits on the payroll and draws a salary while money meant for the frontline disappears unnoticed for years. The Charity Fraud Report from BDO and the Fraud Advisory Panel found that insiders were the single biggest source behind 38% of cases, while staff expense fraud accounted for around a quarter.

“Most trustees hear the word fraud and picture a missing donation,” Formby said. “But the real losses are more tedious. It is often a salary that runs on long after someone has left or an expense claim nobody checks.”

Formby’s concern heightened at a recent Charity Recruit online boardroom she hosted, where weak internal controls became a recurring theme. Leaders described conflict of interest registers that had been left unchecked for years and suppliers that nobody had vetted.

Formby traces it back to governance that’s too weak to catch it. “Charities attract people who want to do good, and that goodwill gets mistaken for a safeguard,” she said. “Boards are stretched and papers get waved through. Some trustees even sign off things they have not had time to challenge and fraudsters read those gaps better than the boards do.”

The Charity Commission opened 603 fraud and 99 cybercrime cases in a single year and lists fraud as a leading risk in its Sector Risk Assessment 2025. Those same weak controls leave charities exposed to online threats. The government’s Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2025/2026 found 28% of charities suffered a breach or attack in the last 12 months, with phishing the most common route in. A board stretched too thin to question a fake supplier is the same board that misses a fraudulent invoice or a phishing email, and a single leak of supporters’ contact and payment details can undo years of donor trust.

The legal stakes have risen sharply since the failure to prevent fraud offence took effect on 1 September 2025, holding large organisations, charities included, criminally liable without reasonable prevention measures. Earlier this year, a manager at a Scottish food firm admitted inventing fake agency workers to pocket £550,000.

When the damage surfaces, it reaches Formby, because charities reach out to her to replace whoever failed to stop it. “When governance breaks, it surfaces as a leadership problem,” she said. “A chief executive leaves under a cloud or a finance director walks, and I am then consulted into a role carrying a reputational mess.”

To remedy this, Formby wants boards and HR leaders to treat fraud as a question of people and culture, not a line in the accounts. “Find out who is really on your payroll and who can approve a payment alone, then look hard at the board. If nobody there can read a set of accounts and ask the uncomfortable question, that is the hire to make this year.”

About Charity Recruit

Charity Recruit is a specialist executive search firm within the Exec Recruit Group, placing leaders across the UK charity and not-for-profit sector. It handles Chief Executive, Director, Trustee and Non-Executive Director appointments for organisations, including local charities, hospices, national bodies and international development organisations. Charity Recruit also runs networking events and peer-to-peer roundtables for charity sector professionals. For more information, visit charityrecruit.co.uk.

Emily Formby is Divisional Director at Charity Recruit, where she places chief executives and senior leaders across the UK charity and not-for-profit sector. She hosts the Charity Champions Podcast, speaking with charity leaders about the realities of leadership in the sector.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *