In June, the Charity Commission strengthened its guidance on raising concerns about conduct within charities. An improved online form now allows evidence uploads and clearer signposting for the public, trustees, employees and volunteers to report serious incidents or matters of material significance. This piece explores the increasing risks charities face from serious incident reporting, and how specialist insurers assess and respond to these risks from an underwriting and claims perspective.

For charities, this change matters. Serious incident reporting impacts governance, risk and reputation. A report can be the right thing to do but still trigger scrutiny, stakeholder questions and an urgent need to evidence good decision making.

Removing reporting barriers

The Commission’s change is designed to reduce confusion about who should report, what to report and where to report. In practice, the clearer signposting and easier evidence submission should make it easier for concerns to be reported.

It also changes the risk landscape for charities in several ways.

First, issues can surface faster. A safeguarding concern, a financial irregularity, a cyber incident, or a serious governance breakdown can be notified to the regulator (together with documented evidence) faster. Secondly, reports can come from different sources. A member of the public with a concern should have a clearer idea of how to report it. Thirdly, scrutiny is more likely to include the charity’s response to an incident. The Commission’s guidance places weight on how trustees manage risk and act when problems arise, not just on the event that triggered attention.

Reporting serious incidents and matters of material significance

Charity trustees are expected to report serious incidents to the Charity Commission when an event or risk could result in significant harm to beneficiaries, staff, volunteers or others, significant loss of charity money or assets, major reputational damage, or other serious impacts on the charity’s work. The Commission’s guidance is clear that timely reporting supports effective regulation and good governance.

Matters of material significance sit alongside this, with a different reporting obligation. Auditors and independent examiners have statutory duties to report certain matters to the relevant charity regulator, and guidance exists to help them identify what must be reported and the need for timely action.

A charity dealing with suspected fraud, weak financial controls, safeguarding failures, or serious cyber disruption may need to consider trustee reporting duties, while also anticipating that the external scrutiny of accounts and governance could trigger a separate report through the material significance route.

What specialist insurers look for when underwriting

Specialist insurers like Markel assess a charity’s risk profile from a variety of perspectives, including their overall objective and beneficiary profile, and the nature of their operations. The June update does not create new legal obligations, but it has the potential to increase the speed to which incidents and concerns (together with the related evidence) are notified to the regulator.

Underwriters tend to think about issues such as how clear accountability is at trustee and senior management level for safeguarding, finance, data and operational risk. What controls exist around money movement, approvals and oversight of third-party suppliers? What processes are in place for a charity to manage complaints, whistleblowing and escalation? Is there a disciplined approach to incident response, record keeping and communications?

Insurers also pay attention to how charities respond following an incident. Reporting should be treated as part of clear risk management processes. Decisions should be documented, thorough minutes kept and show what changed after an incident. That matters because the best indicator of future loss is often the quality of governance today.

How claims teams respond when something goes wrong

When a claim occurs, a claims handler will want to see early notification, appropriate containment and clear evidence, ideally documented soon after the incident. Clear timelines, details of what decisions were taken and supporting documentation is invaluable, especially when multiple stakeholders are involved.

Claims support can involve coordinating legal advice, specialist expertise and communications handling, depending on the nature of the incident and the cover in place. The goal is to reduce harm and limit escalation.

Serious incident reporting is important to a charity’s operations. The summer update makes it easier for concerns to be raised and evidenced. Charities appropriate governance, escalation channels and disciplined responses will be best placed to protect beneficiaries and reassure stakeholders. The enhanced online form and improved evidence upload capability makes it more likely that a concern reaches the regulator with the detail that’s needed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *